Blogs

Top 10 Questions Patients Ask About Scar Protocol—Answered by a Top Cosmetic Surgeon

October 7, 2025

When it comes to post-surgical scar management, patients are increasingly seeking evidence-based solutions that deliver real results. As a leading cosmetic surgeon who has witnessed countless scar treatment journeys, I've compiled the most frequently asked questions about Scar Protocol, a revolutionary comprehensive scar management system that's changing how we approach scar care.

Unlike traditional scar treatments that begin after scars form, Scar Protocol starts from when you receive your incision through to a year afterward for every stage of maturation. This proactive approach has generated significant interest—and questions—from patients worldwide. Let's dive into the top concerns and curiosities I encounter in my practice.

1. What Makes Scar Protocol Different from Other Scar Treatments?

This is perhaps the most common question I receive, and for good reason. The market is flooded with scar treatment options, from simple silicone sheets to complex laser therapies. What sets Scar Protocol apart is its comprehensive, phase-based approach.

Scar Protocol has the most before and afters of scars from across the body, 4 years of rigorous clinical testing that allowed for the formula to be refined and perfected, and all ingredients—with the exception of silicone—come from natural sources. This isn't just another cream; it's a complete system designed to support every stage of scar healing.

The protocol begins immediately after surgery, not weeks or months later when problematic scarring has already begun. The system starts with a healthy dose of aloe vera and vitamin E to moisturize and cleanse the incision scar, creating an exclusive blend of ingredients that helps promote an ideal environment for healing.

2. Who Is the Ideal Candidate for Scar Protocol?

Patient selection is crucial for any treatment's success. You may be a candidate for Scar Protocol if you are going to have surgery or had surgery within the last 6 months. This timeline is important because it captures the critical window when scar tissue is still forming and most responsive to intervention.

The system works particularly well for patients undergoing elective surgeries like cosmetic procedures, reconstructive surgeries, or gender-affirming surgeries. One patient testimonial particularly stands out: "After top surgery, I wanted to try Scar Protocol to avoid the onslaught of scar healing advice and products. While I was initially skeptical, Scar Protocol has made my healing journey smooth and easy. I am so glad I decided to give this product a shot!"

3. How Long Does the Complete Treatment Take?

Understanding the treatment timeline helps set realistic expectations. Your scar will continue to heal for 12 to 18 months after your surgery, and Scar Protocol is designed to support this entire journey. The system includes five distinct phases, each targeting specific stages of scar maturation.

Phase V of Scar Protocol is the retinol cream, providing the finishing touches and wrapping up the first year of healing. Patients appreciate having a structured approach rather than guessing when to switch treatments or wondering if they're doing enough for their scars.

4. What Results Can I Realistically Expect?

Setting realistic expectations is fundamental to patient satisfaction. While scars do not go away completely, significant improvement is achievable with proper treatment. Patient testimonials provide real-world evidence of what's possible.

One patient shared: "My provider has Scar Protocol which I've been using, which has made my scars very supple. A lot of times the scar tissue tightens and binds up, I haven't had that". Another noted: "Definitely at the beginning, you don't see that end target, and the scar looks a little gnarly, but just stick with it, be consistent, use it twice a day, and you'll see really good results".

5. Is There Scientific Evidence Supporting This Approach?

Evidence-based practice is the cornerstone of modern medicine. Silicone sheeting or gel is universally considered as the first-line prophylactic and treatment option for hypertrophic scars and keloids, with efficacy and safety demonstrated in many clinical studies.

Scar Protocol incorporates these proven elements while adding complementary ingredients backed by research. Initial strategies to minimize scar formation include measures to reduce skin tension, and to provide taping, hydration and ultraviolet protection of the early scar tissue—all principles integrated into the protocol's comprehensive approach.

6. What If I'm Not Satisfied with My Results?

This concern is completely understandable, especially given the investment in both time and resources. Scar Protocol offers a 90-day money back satisfaction guarantee, standing behind their product with the belief that you will be satisfied within 90 days, and if not, you can return your kit within the 90-day window for a full refund with no questions asked.

This guarantee demonstrates confidence in the product's effectiveness while providing patients with peace of mind. It's rare to find such comprehensive guarantees in the scar treatment market.

7. Can I Use Scar Protocol for Non-Surgical Scars?

While primarily designed for surgical scars, the system's versatility extends beyond the operating room. One patient reported: "Scar Protocol changed the speed of my scar healing after my surgery and even after a bike wreck. I always want to have this on hand as it provides the best results for any kind of scar".

However, for optimal results with non-surgical scars, timing remains crucial. The sooner treatment begins after injury, the better the potential outcome.

8. How Does Professional Evaluation Factor into Treatment?

Professional guidance enhances treatment success. You can send a photo of your scar and one of their dedicated scar experts will review and respond within 24 hours if your scar is a good candidate for the system. This personalized evaluation helps ensure you're using the right treatment for your specific situation.

Regular re-evaluation of patients every four to eight weeks helps evaluate whether additional treatment is warranted. This ongoing assessment allows for treatment adjustments based on your scar's response.

9. What About Combining Scar Protocol with Other Treatments?

Multimodal therapy often yields superior results. Invasive treatment options include intralesional injections of corticosteroids and/or 5-fluorouracil, cryotherapy, radiotherapy, laser therapy and surgical excision, all of which may be used alone or as part of combination therapy.

While Scar Protocol provides comprehensive care, some patients benefit from additional interventions like laser therapy or steroid injections for particularly challenging scars. Always consult with your surgeon before combining treatments.

10. When Should I Be Concerned About My Healing Scar?

Understanding normal versus problematic healing is essential. After surgery, your wound may be very red, swollen, or feel numb, and after several weeks, the scar may feel hard, tight, raised, or bumpy, but over time, it will become softer, smoother, and less red.

It's important to have a dermatologist examine your scar because sometimes skin cancer can look like a scar—if you see a scar on your skin and don't remember injuring your skin, immediately make an appointment to see a board-certified dermatologist.

Conclusion: Your Journey to Better Scar Healing

The questions addressed here reflect the genuine concerns and hopes of patients navigating their scar healing journey. Scar Protocol represents a paradigm shift in scar management—moving from reactive treatment to proactive, comprehensive care.

Remember, each patient should receive a personalized treatment regimen to optimize scar management. While Scar Protocol offers a structured, evidence-based approach, your individual healing journey is unique. Consistency, patience, and proper guidance are your allies in achieving the best possible outcome.

Whether you're preparing for surgery or currently in the healing process, understanding your options empowers you to make informed decisions about your care. The evolution of scar treatment continues, but with systems like Scar Protocol, we're closer than ever to minimizing the lasting impact of surgical scars on our patients' lives.

For more information about whether Scar Protocol is right for you, consult with your cosmetic surgeon or visit their website for a personalized scar evaluation. Your journey to optimal scar healing begins with taking that first informed step.